By Sharie Reyes Albers, Partner, Virginia Family Law Center
When your spouse has broken your trust, it is natural to want the law to acknowledge that wrong. You feel hurt, you’re likely angry, and you want the record to show exactly what happened. In Virginia, you have the option to file for a Fault-Based Divorce, but as your attorney, my job isn’t just to help you seek vengeance—it’s to help you secure your future.
Our firm has been helping Virginia since 2009 and in that time we’ve seen that “having your day in court” and “getting the best result” are often two different paths. Deciding which one to take is the most critical strategic choice we will make together.
Fault vs. No-Fault Divorce in Virginia: At-a-Glance Comparison
| Feature | No-Fault Divorce | Fault-Based Divorce |
| Separation Period | 6-12 Months | None (for Adultery/Felony) |
| Evidence Needed | Proof of Separation | Corroborated Misconduct |
| Alimony Impact | Standard Review | Possible Permanent Bar |
| Best For | Lower Conflict/Cost | Leverage/Immediate Relief |
The Three Real Reasons to File for Divorce (And it’s Not Always About Fault)
Most people think the grounds (like Adultery or Cruelty) are the most important part of the filing. In reality, as a “steady hand” guide, I look at your case through a different lens. In my experience, there are three primary reasons you might need to move forward with a court filing immediately:
-
Transparency: You don’t know the full extent of your marital assets or liabilities, and we need the court’s subpoena power to find the truth.
-
The Moving Goalpost: Your spouse won’t agree to sign a settlement, or worse, they keep promising to sign “if you just change one more thing” until you’re exhausted and broke.
-
Immediate Financial Need: You need access to temporary child support or spousal support now via a pendente lite hearing, and you can’t wait for a six or twelve-month separation period to run.
The Trap of “Being Nice”
One of the hardest situations I see is when a client is so scared of the courtroom—which is a totally normal feeling—that they do everything possible to avoid it.
They try to stay in the “No-Fault” lane, negotiating in good faith. Meanwhile, their spouse moves the goalposts over and over again. Their spouse agrees to terms, then backs out, then asks for “one more tweak.” By the time the client realizes their spouse has no intention of signing, they have exhausted their emotional and financial resources.
Sometimes, filing on Fault Grounds (like Adultery, Cruelty, or Desertion) is the only way to bring the “gravity of the court” into the room. It stops the games and forces a timeline.
When Fault Matters: Alimony and the House
While my default is a ‘shrewd negotiator’ approach, there are times when being a **’Mama Bear’—not a ‘Shark’—**is exactly what the case requires. It means I’m not looking for a fight, but I am prepared to use the full weight of the law to protect your future when it’s under threat:
-
The Alimony Bar: Under Va. Code § 20-107.1, if we prove adultery, the court generally bars that spouse from receiving support. However, I always warn my clients about the “Manifest Injustice” exception—a judge can still award support if denying it would be fundamentally unfair based on your financial history.
-
Asset Dissipation: If your spouse spent marital money on an affair or a felony, we aren’t just going to “split” what’s left. Under Equitable Distribution (Va. Code § 20-107.3), we fight to have those wasted funds credited back to you.
The Verdict: Is it Worth it?
Filing for fault is a tool, not a trophy. It is often more expensive, more exhausting, and requires “clear and convincing” evidence (like private investigators or forensic audits) that can take an emotional toll on your family.
Our goal as a firm is to get you to the place where you are happily divorced. Sometimes that requires a “zealous advocate” who will fight when provoked, and sometimes it requires a “steady hand” who knows when a no-fault settlement is the fastest, most cost-effective path to your new life.
About Virginia Family Law Center, P.C.
At Virginia Family Law Center, we don’t just practice law; we provide a steady hand for individuals navigating the most turbulent seasons of their lives. Since 2009, our firm has served Northern Virginia as a dedicated advocate for those facing divorce, custody disputes, and complex financial settlements.
A Note from Sharie Reyes Albers
I’ve built a community of over 100,000 people on TikTok because I believe that divorce isn’t about who’s right—it’s about who’s prepared. If you’re feeling stuck between wanting justice and wanting peace, let’s talk about the strategy that actually protects your future.
